Black coffee in a white mug
Michelle and Tim Wunderlich roast in Seaside and pour on Holladay. The Coffee House is still the room with the plants, the yearbooks, and the regulars who do not need a menu.
Cove Tales · March 4, 2026 · 2 min read

Matt Love walked into Seaside Coffee House on a gray Thursday in 2016, ordered the angst-ridden writer special — black coffee in a white mug — and Michelle Wunderlich had it ready the way a regular’s drink is ready. Tim and Michelle Wunderlich own the roasting and the room. The shop on the sign is the Coffee House. The beans are Seaside Coffee Roasters. The address is 5 North Holladay, a block that is not Broadway and does not want to be.
Journey here
In 2016 Matt Love, writing for Discover Our Coast, described a room that mixed hanging plants, old bicycles, and Seaside High yearbooks, and then ordered the same black coffee he always ordered. The photographs still look like that room. The Yelp page now says woman-owned. The website, seasidecoffeeroaster.com, still belongs to the house. Across the street, Beach Books lists Annika Wunderlich on staff — college, cats, coffee, and a line of their own: when she is not at Beach Books, she is at the Coffee House. The roasting and the bookselling have been nodding at each other on Holladay for years.
A normal day
Six to two on weekdays, seven to two on Sunday, a little later on a summer Saturday. Espresso, drip, smoothies, tea, baked goods, breakfast and a short lunch. Silent reading, first Wednesday of the month. Reviewers talk about avocado toast, a London Fog, a Mexican mocha, the barista who knows a name. Pirates Booty is a dark roast on the board. The work is the roast, the pour, and the decision to stay a living room instead of a to-go window on Broadway.
A customer moment
Love’s column is still the best customer moment on the public record: Michelle launching into a story about her teenage daughter, an obsessive reader, writing a dystopian tale that had caught a teacher. The writer told the kid, through the mother, to set the series in a future Seaside with no tourists. The drink was already on the table. That is the shop. The Fourth of July crowd, reviewers say, still moves.
What visitors should know
It is Holladay, not the Prom. Sit at the window if you want the street; sit in the plants if you want to stay. If you want beans, they roast them here. If you want a book after, Beach Books is across the street, and someone in that family may already be on both sides of it. Silent reading night is the first Wednesday. Do not expect a tourist menu. Expect a white mug.
Black coffee in a white mug.

